Menu of Athenian Greek Cuisine in Merrillville, Indiana, USA

Menu Overview

Athenian Greek Cuisine, located in Merrillville, Indiana, offers an inviting gateway into authentic Greek flavors that resonate with both traditionalists and newcomers alike. From the moment you step inside, the familial charm and warm hospitality set the tone for a genuine dining experience, echoed by multiple guests who praised the attentive and friendly service despite the occasional hiccup typical of a family-run establishment.

The menu is a well-curated celebration of classic Greek dishes, each prepared with care and generous portions. The standout offerings include the Charbroiled Lamb Chops, which critics describe as tender and flavorful, paired effortlessly with their hallmark sides of Greek potatoes, rice pilaf, and green beans. These sides not only complement but elevate the main protein, delivering balanced and hearty satisfaction in every bite.

The Athenian Platter shines as a must-try, especially for first-timers or those who prefer variety. Serving up spanakopita—light yet rich spinach and feta phyllo pies—and succulent gyro meat noted for its tenderness and lack of greasiness, this platter is both a culinary sampler and a feast, recommended by diners for its size and quality.

Appetizers such as dolmades (grape leaves stuffed with rice and beef topped with a lemon-based sauce) offer traditional tastes that range from “okay” to delightful, while the grilled octopus has garnered particular praise for its perfect tenderness and seasoning, illustrating the kitchen’s adeptness at handling diverse Greek staples.

Salads and sides remain fresh and vibrant, with the Greek Salad praised for its crispness and the freshly baked bread served alongside often highlighted as a subtle but notable touch. The culinary journey rounds off with authentic desserts like baklava and rich chocolate mousse, the latter observed as a tempting treat that many find hard to resist despite ample portions.

What makes Athenian Greek Cuisine truly exceptional is its consistency and commitment to authenticity. Guests repeatedly highlight the restaurant’s ability to deliver genuine Greek flavors that melt in your mouth, whether it’s a weekday meal or the special BBQ lamb featured on weekends.

In conclusion, Athenian Greek Cuisine doesn’t just serve food—it serves an experience rooted in Greek tradition, generous hospitality, and bold, fresh flavors. If you’re seeking a hearty meal with a diverse menu that respects authentic preparation while embracing a warm, family atmosphere, this is a destination worth savoring.